Anesthetic Options – Awake, Asleep, or In-Between?

Picture of wild iris

Anesthetic Options

Anesthesia is defined as lack of sensation or perception. The development of modern anesthesia techniques, largely within the 20th century, drastically changed the landscape of surgery. The ability to safely block pain, or even entire consciousness, has allowed much more extensive procedures to be performed than ever in history.

Because of the advances made in this field, there are now different options available to optimize patient comfort while minimizing risk, and sometimes minimizing cost. This post will describe some of the nuances of different anesthetic options as they relate to the different operations that I perform as a board certified plastic surgeon.

Some Definitions

Local anesthesia: Injection or topical application of medications that temporarily inactivate pain nerves, resulting in a numb or “deadened” feeling in a specific area. This may be used by itself (i.e. for an awake procedure) or with other forms of anesthesia to improve the body’s response during or after surgery. Injection of local anesthetic medications causes a brief burning sensation. This is minimized by slowing the injection, warming the medication, injecting while pulling the needle back, and buffering the pH of the medication with sodium bicarbonate. 

General anesthesia: “Going to sleep.” This form of anesthesia involves giving medications, usually through a combination of intravenously and through anesthetic gas, to render a patient temporarily unconscious with absolutely no awareness of the ongoing procedure. In my practice general anesthesia is always combined with local anesthetic injections for maximal patient comfort.

General anesthesia is very safe. Patients with reasonably good health have an extremely low chance of serious problems with general anesthetic. 

Sedation: Administration of intravenous or inhaled medications to minimize awareness while not taking away consciousness completely. Performed without a secured airway.

Although sedation is often thought of by patients as the perfect blend of lack of awareness of what’s going on and being fully asleep, in reality sedation is usually the worst of both worlds. Sedation often prevents patients from following instructions (like holding still) while not allowing a deeper level of anesthesia due to lack of airway protection. This may cause a dangerous situation, or require that general anesthesia be induced in a less-controlled fashion (neither of which is positive).  

Regional nerve block: Injection of local anesthetic to specific large nerves to numb a wider area. May be used with any of the above forms of anesthesia.

What Makes a Successful Operation

Safety is my first priority in surgery.  Although every type of anesthesia may be used safely, overdoing certain types of anesthesia, particularly local anesthesia and sedation, may be risky. 

These risks are usually related to medication overdose. Medication overdoses typically fall into four categories: numbing medications (local anesthetics), pain medications (specifically narcotics), anti-anxiety medications (like Xanax® and Valium®), and sedatives/general anesthetics (like propofol).

General anesthetic agents are not widely used for sedation (and never for operations under local anesthesia), so complications due to overdose are quite rare, since operations under general anesthesia usually involve airway protection and medications used to counteract overdose through an IV. Therefore we will focus on the first three categories: local anesthetics, anti-anxiety, and pain medications. 

Local anesthetics – Overdose of local anesthetics (like lidocaine, bupivicaine. Historically, novocain®, which has not been used for about 70 years) cause cardiac and nervous system problems. This can result in a metallic taste sensation, ringing in the ears, seizures, cardiac arrhythmias, arrest. Treatment involves supportive care and Intralipid® which helps to sequester the medication and prevent further effects. Prevention involves staying below maximal safe doses of medication. The takeaway is that procedures under local anesthesia should only be planned when less that the maximal amount of anesthetic is anticipated. 

Pain medications – Too much pain medication, specifically narcotics, causes a “depression” of the respiratory center of the brain. In other words, too many narcotics may make someone stop breathing. Treatment includes naloxone (Narcan®) to block the receptors targeted by narcotics. Prevention involves using pain medication only as necessary, rather than on a schedule. If local anesthetic has been used, in addition to careful surgical practices, pain levels will be tolerable (still present) and narcotics may be used sparingly. 

Anti-anxiety agents – Benzodiazepine medications, such as Xanax and Valium, may cause changes in vital signs and loss of consciousness. In combination with pain medications, this may result in life-threatening problems. If overdose occurs, a medication called flumazenil is used to reverse sedation. Like pain medication, prevention involves using the medication as sparingly as possible, keeping the edge off of a procedure without knocking out the patient. 

A Wide Scope

Plastic and reconstructive surgery encompasses a wide range of operations. The range of patients treated by our specialty has been described as “head to toe, cradle to the grave.” Because of the vast scope of operations performed, listing each one and the corresponding anesthetic options is not feasible. However, there are some guidelines that may help determine what form(s) of anesthesia are most appropriate.

Operative Time

Generally speaking, the shorter the operation, the lower the level of anesthesia that can be used for a successful procedure. Local anesthesia may prevent surgical pain, but longer procedures may still be uncomfortable because of maintaining positioning, boredom, or anxiety.  

Expected Surgical Pain

The more surgical pain that is likely to occur in a procedure, the more numbing medication required to make the operation comfortable, and the more overall discomfort that will be experienced. These procedures favor a higher level of anesthesia, preferably general anesthesia. Conversely, some operations, such as labiaplasty, work very well with local anesthesia because of unique factors causing less-than-average pain.  

Psychological Factors

Different people have different tolerances for medical procedures, in others or themselves. Some procedures that are tolerated very well by one person may be difficult to get through for another. If a patient is concerned about their ability to tolerate a surgery under local anesthesia, they are correct, and general anesthesia is the right choice. 

Examples

Below are some examples of surgeries that work best with specific types of anesthesia. Some of these examples are recommendations, some of them are essentially requirements.
 
Lesion removal – Removal of skin cancers, moles, and thickened scars can usually be removed easily with local anesthesia. Pain control afterwards is usually Tylenol and ibuprofen. 
 
Facial rejuvenation – Depends on the extent of the operation. Browlift or necklift are often well-tolerated under local anesthesia. Upper eyelid lift is almost always well-tolerated awake. Lower eyelid lift is a very different operation and requires general anesthesia. Facelifts, especially in combination with neck lift or other operations, is better tolerated asleep. 
 
Nonsurgical interventions – Botox® and filler injections, very rarely require anesthesia at all . Laser treatments depend on the type of laser and the amount of area treated. As a general rule, the more effective the laser the deeper the level of anesthesia required. 
 
Breast augmentation – General anesthesia is the best choice for breast augmentation. Local anesthesia may be used if implants are placed over the muscle, but this is not usually advised. 
 
Body contouring surgery – These operations, such as tummy tuck, arm lift or thigh lift, and lower body lift, almost always require general anesthesia due to large amounts of skin and tissue removed and the potential of local anesthetic overdose. 
 
Labiaplasty – As mentioned above, labiaplasty works very well with local anesthesia due to the effectiveness of local anesthesia creams which greatly decrease the ability of patients to feel the numbing medication injections. As a result patients are very comfortable throughout the procedure. 
 

Conclusion

In conclusion, there are different options available for anesthesia. When applied correctly and safely patients benefit from flexibility that may improve their overall experience and achieve their surgical goals. Thank you for taking the time to read this. Please call, email, or fill out a contact form so that we may help you today!
 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *